Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Eric's avatar

The problem with Randle is that he isn't doing the things that help the team the most and he isn't doing a very good job of the things he's choosing to do. The crazy shooting that carried him last year isn't back and instead of finding another way to help he's actually helping even less in terms of blocking out and defense. He can handle, drive and do anything on the court but he isn't elite at everything on the court and the big improvement we saw last year from so many players on the team was cutting out the things that don't work and repeating the things that do work. Randle seems to be doing the opposite.

Every way you look at this team screams to play more guys for fewer minutes. Everything about the post covid reality says you should be playing more guys for more minutes. Everything about player development and even getting to and going further in the playoffs is best served by playing more guys fewer minutes in the regular season.

Randle shouldn't be playing more than 20-25 minutes a night at this point. When he starts shooting better or at least figures out how to help when he isn't shooting he can increase a little but we shouldn't have guys on the floor for any longer than they can play hard both ways. He might be able to play at top speed for 40 minutes but he sure hasn't been. You can't tell me that the extra 10 minutes from Randle every night isn't better used on Grimes, Duce & Obi. In a playoff game I get it but what are we even trying to achieve? Creepy stuff like a thibs battle with the front office or Randle being a bad teammate are the only things that really fit what were seeing on the floor.

You can grasp at straws like "guys learn in practice" and thibs must be trying to do this or that but thibs is simply refusing to look at any of the players the front office brings in unless he's forced to by several layers of injury. Even Quickley and Obi had to wait for injury and or play so well they make it impossible for thibs to hide them. Even then they get pigeonholed into roles from which escape is virtually impossible.

I think Dolan prefers an organizational style that promotes conflict and that Thibs has power he shouldn't. Defense is great but what I see is that Randle and RJ are really good players when they hit 3's at over 40% and if they don't Thibs doesn't have anything else in his bag.

Rose, Taj, Bullock, Elf and Randle aren't the core of anything. They are all valuable pieces and Randle is a nice third piece on a championship team if he's willing but I don't think we want to build a team around Randle and I know we don't want to build a team around Thibs. I don't object to hard nosed players who defend but I do object to a coach who can't or won't perform when he doesn't get his way.

Expand full comment
Luis Rivera's avatar

The problem as you have eloquently detailed and I have been spouting for weeks is Thibs insistence in making Randle the next Lebron James. The offense cannot continue to be led by Julius point blank end of story

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts