33 Comments

KP played 38 minutes last night.. Joe can keep that up and see how it turns out. I think we need to slow on the hindsight of going after KP after only one game.

Expand full comment

Why they didn't make a serious attempt at getting KP I'll never understand. He would cost us alot less than any of the other options and exactly what we need: rim protection and shooting. Embid? Let's see, I think that it'll be another Utah situation, the Knicks will have to pay a massive premium and they still might not get him. After that who's left? We're going to be good this year, but probably same fate as last season. 45-50 wins and 2nd round. Frustrating.

Expand full comment

I really liked how RJ played last night he kept the team afloat for a stretch IIRC. My guy Randle shot like shit, 3-4 misses were on one possession tbf, but he was rebounding like crazy & moving the ball. If Randle is going to flirt with a triple double in the flow of the game that's major.

Expand full comment

So glad you gave IHart a star. I thought he was really good. You know, Memphis should probably trade for him with Steven Adams missing the season...... GTFO Memphis fans!

Also, do you think other teams and fans think Isaiah is a dirty player because I bet they do and I don’t give a shit

Expand full comment

I missed my day after newsletter and coffee... it’s the little things in life! Not sure if I missed it on the post game, but the start of the game was strange. I felt JB got some good looks and maybe it was just opening night nerves, but his shots seemed short. I also felt KP’s blocks or presence in the middle impacted the game.

The only thing Boston is good for is a cream donut... let’s go Knicks!!

Expand full comment
Oct 26, 2023·edited Oct 26, 2023

Just want to start off by saying I look forward to another excellent season of newsletter content and writing! That said, I have a couple quick thoughts about the game.

First, I wonder if Thibs expected the Celtics to start Jrue on Randle and Brown on Brunson… I am guessing no.

Looking on the bright side, I think last night confirmed that IQ and RJ are going to have really strong seasons. IQ did IQ things as expected, and RJs overall performance, process, and defense was encouraging (especially given the fact that the Celtics have arguably been the hardest matchup for him, and he has at times struggled greatly against them).

And finally, a question popped into my head last night, again RJ centered, which I am curious to hear your response: if this is the version of RJ we are going to get this season, is there a chance he finishes top 2 in minutes played for the team? My line of thinking comes down to how much run he will get with the bench, which then gets extended when the starters come back in and he stays out there (as we saw in the 2nd quarter).

Expand full comment

Not gonna get emotional bc it’s one game that was much closer than I thought it’d be tbh, but it definitely stings:

Losing a winnable game is one thing; losing a game that you absolutely SHOULD have and would have won if only you were able to do the most basic of fundamentals (make free throws) AT HOME is a different thing. And you said it - stealing this game could’ve made a potentially rough early slate a lot less rough.

(I will never, ever, ever understand not putting your best free throw shooter at the line to shoot a technical, especially when he’s on fire and the alternative is ice cold. It makes no sense.)

Expand full comment

Great final thoughts Jon. I think Dollar Bill used to say the great thing about the nba schedule is the games are so close to each other so you don't hang on to the tough losses too long. I am paraphrasing but that was the gist. Last night will be nothing but a memory if they can bring that same competitive fire along with an appearance from either JB or JR or both through the weekend. Let's go Knicks. I can't wait for tomorrow night.

Expand full comment

In regards to all the complaints I've heard about Thibs using a nine man rotation, I decided to look at what other teams doing and while a lot of them had 10 man rotations, most of the players who were the 10th man on the totem pole only played about 5 minutes so I don't know what the big deal is! I think Thibs gets a bad wrap for that!

Expand full comment

Also why is JB untouchable in a trade? I know he’s family and all but like you said the best player on the other team is usually going to be better than him.

Expand full comment

A few words on rebounds. The defensive team generally gets more rebounds than the offensive team- there's supposed to be an advantage there. So when the Knicks missed 61 shots to Boston's 40, Boston 'should' have won the rebounds by 21. For the Knicks to have won it by 1 is a dominant performance. I hope that makes sense, it's always annoyed me that rebounds aren't analyzed more closely.

Make your free throws! Hate to lose to Satan's Celtics, especially when we should have won.

Expand full comment

One word; Quickley

Expand full comment

We have 9 good players this year. RJ sat too long in the 4th quarter. Would have like to see Thibs bring RJ in for Randle rather than for Grimes.

Expand full comment

He was young and immature. He’s admitted that it was a mistake and that he would’ve done it differently if he had a redo. Besides, great, the guy had rings, he’s an arrogant AHOLE and was incompetent as an executive. You get so far on reputation, you still need to earn respect and treat others with respect if you want it back. I’ve told several bosses to go F themselves because they were useless AHOLES riding on reputation! You should try it! So, I assume that you were upset when they brought back D. Rose?

Expand full comment

"If he felt the brunt of positional voting, so should everyone for the rest of time."

Hear, hear! 😂

Expand full comment

I’m surprised the vibes were negative from you on this game. I thought the Knicks came out off but were getting good shots and felt like opening night jitters where they were just coming up too hot. I thought the energy was good and the rotations were fun and they’re going to fix a lot of the stuff that went wrong Opening night. Brunson was just off and that’s not going to happen often. The Celtics are loaded and Porzingis is a perfect fit for them though, I still wouldn’t bet on those knees holding up. I’m happy for him that he’s having success and love him as the villain.

Expand full comment