Discussion about this post

User's avatar
ToddyIce's avatar

Very well written. Extremely objective and, to quote the great JM, a "fair" synopsis.

I will like to stress one point that was cited, but is a bigger deal than most give credence to. Rose turned a middling 500ish team (appropriate with the talent on the team even with an effective Randle) into a 4th seed. Him playing against other team's reserves was a legit weapon that made the bench elite. Plus, he elevated guys like Obi and IQ. His absence was a HUGE deal! However, as stated, our Coach couldn't resist playing him 35 minutes a game, as opposed to the 18-22 minutes his body could withstand, and the inevitable injury occurred...leading back to Thibs...and here we go again...lol

But even with that said, I do believe we need Thibs for where this organization realistically is (after 20 years of hot garbage and terrible drafting). His ethos and old school values is what is necessary and we are seeing results in our young players actually developing. This was never a 2-3 year turnaround unless we lucked up with a generational talent. And the Knicks will never get lucky at anything with the curse of Dolan!

Expand full comment
Future_Considerations's avatar

Damn Macri, you had you're creative writing juices flowing with your "jab-jab-jab-18-footer-brick" line and Randle falling asleep with the read on his chest instead of reacting...all in one tight paragraph. Strong work! Agree as usual with most of your takes, but the start Quickley & Grimes Game 1 is a bit of revisionist history. That seems viable today on 4/4 but that would've been an eye popper to start the season. This season was a pass through and I'm not going to hold the FO's feet to the fire because they tinkered with a team that delivered beyond its wildest expectations and resulted in a 1st ROUND EXIT. They didn't nearly win a championship. They lost in the first frickin' round. That's far from a handle with care scenario. We retool and give it a go again next year, applying the lessons we learned from this year. Done and done.

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts